Disclaimer: This is educational content based on my personal experience, not legal or tax advice. Every situation is different. Consult a qualified attorney and/or CPA for guidance specific to your circumstances.
"Do I need an LLC for my side project?" might be the single most common question I get from people starting something new. It's also the question with the most frustrating answer: it depends.
But "it depends" isn't helpful. So let me break down what an LLC for side projects actually does, when it makes sense to form one, and when you might be better off waiting — based on my own experience structuring GAS Studio and its portfolio of ventures under N-Squared Lifestyle, LLC.
What an LLC Actually Does (And What It Doesn't)
Before we get into whether you need an LLC, let's clarify what one is. An LLC — Limited Liability Company — is a legal entity that separates your business activities from your personal assets. The "limited liability" part means that if your business gets sued or takes on debt, your personal savings, home, and other assets are generally protected.
That's the core value proposition. An LLC creates a legal wall between your business and your personal life.
What it doesn't do: make you look more professional (nobody checks), guarantee tax savings (it's more complex than that), or magically make your side hustle a "real" business. Your business is real the moment someone pays you for something. The LLC is a legal structure, not a legitimacy badge.
Sole Proprietor vs LLC: The Real Difference
When you start selling stickers on Etsy, doing freelance design, or consulting on weekends, you're already a sole proprietor by default. No paperwork required. You earn money, you report it on your personal taxes, you're done.
The sole proprietor vs LLC decision comes down to two questions:
How much risk does this activity carry? If your side project is low-risk — you're selling digital downloads, writing a newsletter, coaching one-on-one — the liability exposure is relatively small. An LLC adds protection, but the risk you're protecting against may not justify the cost and complexity.
If your side project involves physical products (like Sundream Stickers), contracts with other businesses, handling other people's money (like Giveable's model), or anything where someone could get hurt — the calculus changes. The LLC's liability protection becomes more valuable as risk increases.
How much money is this generating? Below a certain revenue threshold, the costs of maintaining an LLC — filing fees, registered agent fees, separate banking, potential accounting costs — can eat into margins that are already thin. If your side project makes $200 a month, spending $500 a year on LLC maintenance might not make sense yet.
There's no magic number, but as a general guideline based on my experience: when your side hustle legal protection needs increase (i.e., you're taking on clients, shipping products, or handling meaningful revenue), it's time to seriously consider forming an LLC.
When to Form an LLC: The Signals
Here are the moments that, in my experience, signal it's time to stop operating as a sole proprietor and form an LLC:
You're signing contracts. The moment you're entering agreements with clients, suppliers, or partners, you want the legal separation. Contracts create obligations, and obligations create risk.
You're earning consistent revenue. "Consistent" matters more than "large." If your side project has become a reliable income stream — even a modest one — that's a signal it's outgrown hobbyist status.
You're investing real money. Buying inventory, paying for advertising, investing in equipment — when you're putting meaningful capital at risk, protecting your personal assets becomes more important.
You're uncomfortable with the risk. This is the most honest signal. If you're losing sleep wondering what happens if a customer sues you or a product causes a problem, the peace of mind alone is worth the filing fee.
You want to build credit and financial history for the business. An LLC can open a business bank account, build business credit, and establish a financial track record that's separate from your personal finances. If you're planning to grow — and at GAS Studio, every venture is built to grow — this foundation matters.
How I Structured GAS Studio
I'll share my setup as a reference point, not a prescription. Every situation is different.
GAS Studio operates under N-Squared Lifestyle, LLC. This is the parent entity. Individual ventures operate under this umbrella rather than each having their own separate LLC. The reasons: simplicity, cost efficiency, and the fact that the ventures share enough operational infrastructure that a single entity makes practical sense at this stage.
As ventures grow and take on their own risk profiles, they may spin out into separate entities. That's a bridge to cross when we get there. For now, the single-entity approach keeps things manageable while still providing the core benefit of separating business from personal liability.
The lesson: don't over-engineer your entity structure too early. Start with the simplest structure that provides adequate protection, and evolve as complexity demands it. The founders who spend three months researching multi-entity holding company structures before they've made their first sale are solving the wrong problem.
The Process (Simpler Than You Think)
Forming an LLC is not the intimidating process the "LLC formation service" industry wants you to believe. For most states, the steps are straightforward.
You choose a name and verify it's available. You file Articles of Organization with your state (usually $50-300 depending on the state). You get an EIN from the IRS (free, takes ten minutes online). You open a business bank account. You draft an operating agreement (especially important if you have partners, but good practice even as a solo member).
That's the basics. You can do it yourself in an afternoon, or pay a service a few hundred dollars to handle it. Either way, it's far less complicated than the internet makes it seem.
The ongoing maintenance varies by state. Some require annual reports and fees. Some don't. Wisconsin, where GAS Studio is based, requires an annual report that takes about five minutes to file.
When NOT to Form an LLC
Not every side project needs one, and forming an LLC prematurely has its own costs.
If it's genuinely a hobby. Making candles for friends and occasionally selling one at a craft fair? You probably don't need a formal business entity yet.
If you're still validating the idea. Before you know whether anyone wants what you're building, the energy spent on entity structuring is energy not spent on finding out. Test first. Structure later.
If the cost would strain you. If the filing fees and maintenance costs represent a meaningful financial burden, you might be better served putting that money into the business itself and revisiting the LLC question when revenue can absorb the cost.
The right time to form an LLC is when the protection it provides is worth more than the cost and complexity it introduces. That's a personal calculation that depends on your risk tolerance, your revenue, and your growth plans.
The Takeaway
Do you need an LLC for your side project? Maybe not today. But if you're building something real — something that involves risk, revenue, and relationships with other people's money or trust — you'll want one eventually.
Start simple. Protect what matters. Don't over-engineer. And when in doubt, spend a few hundred dollars on a conversation with a lawyer or CPA who can look at your specific situation. It's one of the best investments you can make early in a venture's life.
This is educational content, not legal or tax advice. For questions about your specific situation, please consult a qualified professional. Follow the Journal for more practical insights on building ventures, or get in touch to connect.
This entry is part of our Purpose & Impact series. Subscribe to the GAS Studio Journal RSS feed to stay in the loop.
